Get the latest tech news

Medical Benchmarks and the Myth of the Universal Patient


From growth charts to anemia thresholds, clinical standards assume a single human prototype. Why are we still using one-size-fits-all health metrics?

The coördinating team recruited participants from six far-flung locations: Oslo, Norway; Muscat, Oman; Pelotas, Brazil; New Delhi, India; Accra, Ghana; and, as it happens, the city where I live, Davis, California. Among low-income families in urban India, Sachdev noted, ambitious interventions targeting health, sanitation, nutrition, and psychosocial support have failed to increase stature by half a standard deviation, suggesting that differences among sites may reflect disparate physiological baselines. Even with these advances, Pontzer suspects another reason for the reluctance to discuss biological variation: “Differences are dangerous.” Throughout history, claims of inherent disparities have fuelled oppression, from the justification of slavery to the forced sterilization of the poor.

Get the Android app

Or read this on Hacker News

Read more on:

Photo of myth

myth

Photo of medical benchmarks

medical benchmarks

Photo of universal patient

universal patient

Related news:

News photo

The Myth of Bananaland

News photo

The Myth of the Loneliness Epidemic

News photo

The Origins of the Climate Haven Myth