Get the latest tech news

MIT paper on AI for materials research found to be fraudulent


The red flags we should have seen earlier for a too-good-to-be-true paper on AI tool adoption at a materials research firm

Why would a large company like this take such pains to run a randomized trial on its own employees, tracking a number of metrics of their performance, only to anonymously give this data to a single researcher from MIT—a first year PhD student, mind you—rather than publishing the findings themselves? And then, to cap it off, here’s how Toner-Rodgers describes a fortuitous round of layoffs at the firm, that miraculously doesn’t interfere with the data collection for the primary analysis and yet contributes an insightful example that supports his findings: However, it boggles the mind that a random economics student at MIT would be able to easily (and without providing any further details), perform the highly sophisticated technique from the paper he cites ( De et al, 2016), especially in this elegantly formalized manner without any domain expertise in computational materials research.

Get the Android app

Or read this on Hacker News

Read more on:

Photo of MIT

MIT

Photo of MIT paper

MIT paper

Photo of materials research

materials research

Related news:

News photo

MIT Asks arXiv To Take Down Preprint Paper On AI and Scientific Discovery

News photo

MIT Says It No Longer Stands Behind Student's AI Research Paper

News photo

MIT engineering students crack egg dilemma, finding sideways is stronger