Get the latest tech news

New Analysis Casts Doubt On 'Biosignatures' Found On Planet K2-18b


Initial claims that life-associated gases were detected on exoplanet K2-18b are being challenged, with independent reanalysis by Jake Taylor suggesting the data is too noisy to support such conclusions and that stronger, model-independent evidence is needed. NPR reports: Rather than seeing a bump o...

Initial claims that life-associated gases were detected on exoplanet K2-18b are being challenged, with independent reanalysis by Jake Taylor suggesting the data is too noisy to support such conclusions and that stronger, model-independent evidence is needed. NPR reports: Rather than seeing a bump or a wiggle that indicated a signal, "the data is consistent with a flat line," says Taylor, adding that more observations from the telescope are needed to know what can be reliably said about this planet's atmosphere. What this new work shows is that "the strength of the evidence depends on the nitty gritty details of how we interpret the data, and that doesn't pass the bar for me for a convincing detection," says Laura Kreidberg, an expert on the atmospheres of distant planets at the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy in Germany who didn't work on the original research team or this new analysis.

Get the Android app

Or read this on Slashdot

Read more on:

Photo of new analysis

new analysis

Photo of doubt

doubt

Photo of biosignatures

biosignatures

Related news:

News photo

New analysis casts doubt on 'biosignatures' found on planet K2-18B

News photo

Overblown quantum dot conspiracy theories make important points about QLED TVs | Lawsuits and allegations are creating doubt around quantum dot TVs' use of QDs.

News photo

Study casts doubt on gluten as cause of gut ailments among non-coeliacs