Get the latest tech news

Ontology Is Overrated – Categories, Links, and Tags (2005)


Clay Shirky's writings about the Internet, including Economics and Culture, Media and Community, Open Source

The strategy of tagging -- free-form labeling, without regard to categorical constraints -- seems like a recipe for disaster, but as the Web has shown us, you can extract a surprising amount of value from big messy data sets. The more you push in the direction of scale, spread, fluidity, flexibility, the harder it becomes to handle the expense of starting a cataloguing system and the hassle of maintaining it, to say nothing of the amount of force you have to get to exert over users to get them to drop their own world view in favor of yours. And if you can find any way to create value from combining myriad amateur classifications over time, they will come to be more valuable than professional categorization schemes, particularly with regards to robustness and cost of creation.

Get the Android app

Or read this on Hacker News

Read more on:

Photo of categories

categories

Photo of links

links

Photo of tags

tags

Related news:

News photo

Top links on Bluesky, Updated Hourly

News photo

X temporarily blocked users from sharing links to Signal

News photo

X blocks users from sharing links to Signal