Get the latest tech news

US can’t ban TikTok for security reasons while ignoring Temu, other apps

TikTok's survival in the US may depend on an appeals court ruling this December.

And because the law carves out China-owned and controlled e-commerce apps like Temu and Shein—which a US commission deemed a possible danger and allegedly process even more sensitive data than TikTok—the national security justification for targeting TikTok is seemingly so under-inclusive as to be fatal to the government's argument, Pincus argued. Daniel Tenny, a lawyer representing the US government, defended Congress' motivations for passing the law, explaining that the data TikTok collects is "extremely valuable to a foreign adversary trying to compromise the security" of the US. But US circuit judge Neomi Rao pushed back on this, suggesting that disclosure maybe isn't "always" the only appropriate mechanism to block propaganda in the US—especially when the US government has no way to quickly assess constantly updated TikTok source code developed in China.

Get the Android app